S.O.T.M July - Discussion Thread

[Ironhide]

I agree with Devour... Ironhide's sig, for example, doesn't even fit to the theme. x)

Ofc it does.

It is found in a motion picture. Just as the theme says. There are definetely entries fitting less to the theme than mine.

[Numb]

I agree with Devour... Ironhide's sig, for example, doesn't even fit to the theme. x)

Ofc it does.

It is found in a motion picture. Just as the theme says. There are definetely entries fitting less to the theme than mine.

The guy in your signature is not from a film. :p

And yes, there are others who should be disqualified as well.

[Ironhide]

The guy in your signature is not from a film. :p

And yes, there are others who should be disqualified as well.

Shall I tell you the entries ones which are not valid?

First of all let's remind us of the theme itself again:

THEME EXPLANATION:
You can enter with a signature with the focal point found in a film. Explicit Material is NOT allowed.

Alright, the focal point should be found in a film, sounds to me like a render out of a film or a screen from a film.

I start the list with:

Hidden content:

Sharp:

I strongly doubt the cover is part of the film itself, it has something to do with it, sure, but "the focal point is" not "found in a film". Further more it is just a picture he resized, NO GFX stuff in this sig at all!
No valid entry.

Hypexx:

Well partly the same as for Sharp, I doubt that the CD is a render OUT OF A FILM or is "found in a film". I doubt you would call a Blu-Ray player entry valid, so this one does not count either.
No valid entry.

Legend:

Johnny Bravo is an American animated television series created by Van Partible for the Cartoon Network.

A TV show, not a film.
No valid entry.

Numb:

Your signature says "XMen Escape", this is actually a GAME not a film!
http://www.meltgames.com/free-games/348 ... scape.html
Futher more there has no XMen comic film been ever done, just with humans, so it is either a GAME or out of one of many Xmen comic TV SHOWS!

Nuff' said. Have fun with your SOTM.
No valid entry.

Viva:

First of all, this is NOT found in a film. If I would draw something on paper and you can barely see what it is, would it count?
Further more the way he posted his entry is not allowed.

Code: Select all

[img]http://i27.tinypic.com/xc3cc1.png[/img]

According to SOTM rules ( http://www.tx-gaming.net/forums/viewtop ... 151&t=5241 ) the entry has to be posted with CODE: NAME
Let me quote the SOTM rules again.

• Every signature must contain your TeamXtreme username

No TeamXtreme username in this signature!
Plus the same report as Viva (name missing in code brackets).
No valid entry.

Minus:

• Every signature must contain your TeamXtreme username

I doubt Minus has ANY TeamXtreme username at all!
No valid entry.

FlxCore:

• Every signature must contain your TeamXtreme username

I doubt FixCorehas ANY TeamXtreme username at all!
No valid entry.


Ironhide:

Found in a TV show.
No valid entry.

Devour:

Valid entry.

Slayer:

EDIT: Made a mistake. It is valid!
Valid entry.

War:

Valid entry.

Hidden content:

Okay. The S.O.T.M July will be decided between War, Slayer and Devour.
All the other entries are either not posted valid, do not fit to the theme of the SOTM July or broke the general SOTM rules.

Sorry guys, but if you want to do it correctly and get rid of not valid entries, you gotta remove them all! Rule is rule and does not get invalid or ignored for anyone out there!

[GeniuZ]

True that.

[Ironhide]

Btw. I just noticed, if the TeamXtreme username has to be in the sig, how could Sharp exit etc. win previous SOTM's without having ANY TX username?

Sounds to me like you need to change some of the last winners. Yay!

RULE IS RULE BUDDIES! YOU SET THEM UP, NO STICK TO THEM AND FOLLOW THEM! LIVE WITH THE PUNISHMENT FOR BREAKING THE SOTM RULES! NO1 IS SAVE!

YOU CAN CHANGE THEM AFTER THIS SOTM TO AVOID TROUBLE LIKE THAT AGAIN, SAYING "TEAMXTREME USERNAME MUST BE INCLUDED", BECAUSE ATM, ONLY TX MEMBERS CAN TAKE PART. RULES SAID IT. CHANGING DURING A CONTEST WOULD MAKE IT UNFAIR AND NOT A CONTEST ANYMORE; CHANGING RULES TILL IT FITS IS NO OPTION!

[Seany]

Slayer got a name in it... :D

[Ironhide]

Slayer got a name in it... :D

The only text on his sig is:
"Inglorius Basterds - August 21" Not his TX username.

But even if. 3 Valid entries maybe, not more.

[Seany]

Guck doch mal neben dem Messer in dem roten C4D, da steht "Slayer" drinne.

[Pacio]

Rules are rules. They can't be broken.
Though many people has been PWNED.
So just War, Devour and Slayer are competing?

[Ironhide]

Rules are rules. They can't be broken.
Though many people has been PWNED.
So just War, Devour and Slayer are competing?

Yes, only those 3. I can not decide it because I am not in the GFX team, but RULES ARE RULES and I wrote exactly what was not legal. So even though I am not in the GFX team, I am correct, that means only those 3 are in the SOTM July.

[Numb]

First of all, TX username = the username on the TX forums. So ofc they were allowed to win. ^^

Second, Minus' entry is alright, he has his username in it. Same with Flxcore.

Third, my focal point is Wolverine -> Wolverine can be found in a film. The text "escape" is just a random text because it looks like Wolverine is escaping.

I agree with the rest, though.

[Ironhide]

Third, my focal point is Wolverine -> Wolverine is found in a film. The text "escape" is just a random text because it looks like Wolverine is escaping.

You CAN find him in a film but YOURS is not!
You can find EVERYTHING and EVERYONE then in a film. The guy on my sig too, Kevin James, he was also actor in movies *yay* my sig is valid agian.

[Numb]

My character is in a film, yours is not. :)

So just because he's a little cartoon-ish?

And ye, we even wrote that characters from movies are ok a few pages back in this topic. Your manipulated picture of Avelyn is not a movie character. x)

[Ironhide]

My character is in a film, yours is not. :)

So just because he's a little cartoon-ish?

And ye, we even wrote that characters from movies are ok a few pages back in this topic. Your manipulated picture of Avelyn is not a movie character. x)

There is NO Wolverine comic film ever been released, you render does NOT come from a film! Your focal point is NOT found in a film. Definetely violating the theme.

And stop saying it is possible to find this in a film, it is NOT, you can find Xmen in a film but NOT your render. Neither would it be possible taking a sig with Arnold Schwarzenegger as governor and saying he was an actor once, as long as the render is NOT FOUND INA MOVIE OR FILM it is not vailid.

My entry is not vailid, I admit, but neither is yours.

[Numb]

Look, people already asked about this.