Herztsich 'App

Vicper™ · Post by **Vicper™** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 1:28 pm

Good luck.

GeniuZ · Post by **GeniuZ** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:04 pm

1eShit wrote:

I don't need to be Gen to say that, I think that he fullfills the requirements and thats why I say he is good enough.

O rly?
- No!

Which requirements? You are not even long enough part of TX to say whether people fullfill requirements or not.
Again, concerning EVERY SINGLE TX-MEMBER:

DO NOT give statements like "he is good enough, he has got the required skill, he is ready" e.g., the voters and only the voters decide if somebody is good enough or not - you have no idea what the voters think, do you? You can say stuff like "in my opinion, he is not bad/good/awesome", but you cannot say if he is ready to join TX or not.

Read and understand, I won't have discussions with you guys about that, do not reply to this message.

I have played two matches + an 1on1 with him. I am not sure if I am going to vote or not, I would like to play some more matches with you.

Post by **Ironhide** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:30 pm

Another exception. Cool.

Herzstich · Post by **Herzstich** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:32 pm

Thank you guys for writing good things in my Application

it follows a new Rtg today.

Today in the evening I have a lot of time, I hope you are up for some matches ;)

1eShit · Post by **1eShit** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:51 pm

Content has been deleted - spam.

Edit 1eShit:
Yes, way to go GeniuZ (I bet it was you), delete my arguments and consider them as spam, but leave yours here !

Post by **War** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:53 pm

1eShit wrote:Seriously, stop with that "Not long enough in TX" - Shit.
I play RepCom for 5 years now, believe me I have enough experience.
Furthermore the application board is public this means also people who aren't in the clan can read the applications and see who got accepted and who not, means also people who have never been in TX could say that he is good enough or not.

GeniuZ wrote: DO NOT give statements like "he is good enough, he has got the required skill, he is ready" e.g., the voters and only the voters decide if somebody is good enough or not - you have no idea what the voters think, do you? You can say stuff like "in my opinion, he is not bad/good/awesome", but you cannot say if he is ready to join TX or not.
Sure I can say that, if I think he is ready to join I say "He is good enough", and this is kind of freedom of speech. (But I don't want to go that far since it leads to more senseless discussions ...)
And I don't see any problems with that, since I am not able to vote you can give a shit on that, if you think he is not good enough then don't vote for him.

Discuss this on xfire or everywhere else, but not here.
Stop spamming now.
I think you have me on xfire Herzstich, ask me for matches.

Seany · Post by **Seany** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:03 pm

Ironhide wrote:Another exception. Cool.

Indeed. Why me made a rule about it, if we make exceptions for every applicant. why we can't make exceptions for every rule?? Now, I use another namen than "Seany". Nothing against you, Herzstich, but we made a rule and we have to follow it in my opinion...

1StepClØser · Post by **1StepClØser** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:26 pm

@ Seany:
Ye but this rule only exist that we have no kiddys, who are flaming or something else.
Herzstich istn a kiddy. His behavior is better than some others, who are over 15 years old.

Im 15 years old. As i joined TX I was 14. Do u ever had any problems with me?

Aquaz · Post by **Aquaz** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:37 pm

Regeln sind Regeln .. wenn jeder drauft scheißt kann man sie eh wieder abschaffen, bringen ja eh nichts.

Post by **Judge** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:38 pm

GeniuZ wrote:Again, concerning EVERY SINGLE TX-MEMBER:

DO NOT give statements like "he is good enough, he has got the required skill, he is ready" e.g., the voters and only the voters decide if somebody is good enough or not - you have no idea what the voters think, do you? You can say stuff like "in my opinion, he is not bad/good/awesome", but you cannot say if he is ready to join TX or not.

Read and understand, I won't have discussions with you guys about that, do not reply to this message.

I have played two matches + an 1on1 with him. I am not sure if I am going to vote or not, I would like to play some more matches with you.

This is not true. GIVING a statement is not the same as VOTING. The voters are the only members who can actually decide about whether an applicant should join or not, nonetheless any TX member is feel free to give his opinion about any applicant, which include the fact that you can say if you think that he is ready to join or not.

GeniuZ · Post by **GeniuZ** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:51 pm

Where did I say that it is the same?
It's so annoying to read comments which say "he's good enough, he's ready" etc.
You do not take part in discussions where you have no idea about the content, do you? It's the same here: when you haven't been in TX for a quite long time, things are still new or you don't know how things has been handled before, that's why you can't comment about that.
Whatever, keep spamming applications with "yay, he's good enough" then, though it doesn't help a s**t.

Post by **Ironhide** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:58 pm

I actually do agree with Geniuz. Everyone can tell us his opinion, but comments like "vote now!!!" or "he owns let him in" are unnecessary and annoying.

ThaXoZ · Post by **ThaXoZ** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 4:01 pm

GL Herzstich

Hidden content:

Matzey · Post by **Matzey** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 5:09 pm

Oh. I didn't see your application man. :D
Good Luck and ask me for matches.
I've you already in xfire.

Numb · Post by **Numb** » Wed Oct 20, 2010 6:16 pm

It's funny how ALL applications somehow go off-topic... Shit didn't do anything wrong in my opinion. Read his post again.

1eShit wrote:I don't need to be Gen to say that, I think that he fullfills the requirements and thats why I say he is good enough.

Geniuz wrote:You can say stuff like "in my opinion, he is not bad/good/awesome", but you cannot say if he is ready to join TX or not.

Last time i checked, the sentence "I think" means the same as "in my opinion", lol.

And second, I think people can tell their opinions weather a member is ready or not. Of course, the Generals make the decisions, but it is great motivation and support for the applicant. Besides, as long as you've been an applicant yourself and been accepted, you kind of know what it takes to get in, don't you? Once again, the Generals have the full right to post opinions/comments, just like the other members. As long as the comments can motive the applicant and lead him/her in the right way, I think it's fine. Spams like "vote now!!!!!" shouldn't be posted, though. Write something useful. Experiences with the applicant are always useful. So are opinions.

Good luck, Herztsich! Xfire - numb100.

Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App

Re: Herztsich 'App